Media Review Network Media Review Network

Newsflash

Advertisement

Latest News

 
Home arrow World arrow Al-Jazeera Interview: Jaswant Singh
Al-Jazeera Interview: Jaswant Singh PDF Print E-mail
Tuesday, 01 September 2009

 image
 
Singh's book has provoked a storm of reaction in his own country [EPA]  

Jaswant Singh, a former leader with India's main opposition party, has sparked controversy in his own country with a book on Mohammad Ali Jinnah, the founding father of Pakistan.

The Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) expelled Singh over his book Jinnah: India-Partition Independence, which offered a sympathetic portrayal of Jinnah by an Indian writer.

The local government in Gujarat, a state controlled by the BJP, even moved to ban the book, saying it ran counter to public and national interests.

In an interview with Al Jazeera, Singh, a former finance and foreign minister, gave his thoughts on the controversy sparked by his book, as well as on his former political party.

Al Jazeera: When you say that perhaps we need controversy to educate people, that seems to imply that there is some problem for India and Pakistan confronting that history.

Jaswant Singh: We have been manufacturing history, inventing history.

For example, India has demonised Mohammad Ali Jinnah just as Pakistan has demonised Mahatma Gandhi, or [Jawaharlal] Nehru or [Sardar Vallabhbhai] Patel.

They were all Indian. All of them were great Indians. Gandhi and Jinnah were really contemporaries ... and Gandhi himself called Jinnah a great Indian.

In terms of the book that you have written, what is more important - that discussion takes place in India about that history or that Jinnah is viewed differently?

singhs%20book
The book has sparked controversy in India over its portrayal of Mohammed Ali Jinnah
Once the full book is read, [and] the narrative is grasped, then you understand the enormity of the tragedy and the fruitlessness of the partition, certainly to me.

This is not to question the reality of Pakistan, of Bangladesh, but we have to find an answer to the problems of that period.

We created a partition to end peace. There is no peace in Pakistan (inside it), there is no peace in India and there is no peace in Bangladesh. There is no peace between the countries.

You say in the book that "Pakistan is doubtless Muslim but theocentrically it's not a theocratic state". I mean, that's quite a loaded statement to make.

Not at all. "Theocentricism", where society is centred on Islam - this is in line whether Pakistan, India or Bangladesh, where faith is of paramount importance.

Pakistan is not theocratic in the sense it is not the Mullah that is governing Pakistan ... but Pakistan society is governed by Islam. That is the difference. It is a very vital and important difference that has to be understood by the West about Islam.

Should Pakistan be governed in a secular fashion though?

Pakistan should be governed as they determine for themselves ... I can wish that it would be better that they were governed as Jinnah had dreamt that they ought to be governed, but it's for Pakistan to decide.

You say in the book that the modern mind just cannot comprehend Islam precisely because it is a totality. It makes it very difficult for Pakistan to govern in anything that might resemble a secular fashion.

The Western mind cannot grasp the enormity and subtlety of Islam.

India has more Muslims living in it as citizens of India today than Pakistan has. We have lived with Islam for centuries. Islam has been absorbed by the ethos of India.

I think India understands Islam much better than the West does. You see it as an adversary. We see it as part of the Indian vividity. The real renaissance of Islam would have taken place in undivided India if there had not been a partition.

I'm asking you a very personal and direct question because you've been such an integral part of the BJP. Do you take any responsibility for the state of affairs? Do you think that the BJP, not just for the country but for the good of itself, needs to reform?

Of course I take responsibility for everything that the party has done up till the moment of my exit. Until the day, I am a member of the party [and] I am responsible for everything the party has had to do or done.

As it is, the political parties that exist in the country are really functioning like private limited companies or family concerns ... congress of course is purely and unashamedly a family concern and they don't make any bones about it, but the same problems seem to have afflicted my former political party. It has become sycophantic, full of time-servers.

These are not the ideals with which we began. The purpose of the party was the service of the nation.
Last Updated ( Tuesday, 01 September 2009 )
 
[ Back ]

News Feed


Press TV
PRESS TV RSS News
جمع‎آوري 430 هزار خودروي تويوتا
شرکت خودروسازي تويوتا، بيش از 430 هزار دستگاه از خودروهاي گران‎قيمت اين شرکت را از سراسر امريکا و ژاپن جمع‎آوري خواهد کرد.
ورود سران عربستان و سوريه به لبنان
بشار اسد، رئيس‌جمهور سوريه و ملک عبدالله بن عبدالعزيز، پادشاه عربستان باهدف حل تنش‌هاي داخلي لبنان وارد پايتخت اين کشور شده‌اند.
'US creating disunity in Lebanon'
The Hezbollah resistance movement has accused the US of trying to sow the seeds of discord and creating division in Lebanon by interfering in the country's internal affairs.
China denounces EU's Iran sanctions
China has voiced its disapproval of the new unilateral sanctions imposed by the EU against Iran over its nuclear program, urging a negotiated solution through diplomacy.
بيش از 400 کشته در سيل پاکستان
در پي بارش باران شديد و بر اثر بروز سيل در شمال غربي پاکستان، دست‎کم 400 تن کشته و هزاران نفر نيز بي‌خانمان شده‌اند.
BBC News Feed
BBC News - Middle East
Beirut talks seek to ease tension
Syrian President Bashar al-Assad and Saudi Arabia's King Abdullah are in Beirut for talks with Lebanese leaders aimed at calming sectarian tensions.
Saudi warned on expelling Somalis
The UN refugee agency urges Saudi Arabia to stop deporting Somalis, saying 2,000 have recently been sent to Mogadishu.
Arab League endorses direct talks
The Arab League backs direct Palestinian peace talks with the Israelis, but leaves the timing to the Palestinians, officials say.
Gun and bomb attacks hit Baghdad
At least 16 people, including several security force members, are killed in shootings and explosions in the Iraqi capital Baghdad, officials say.
Canada jails Iran nuclear suspect
The Ontario Court of Justice in Canada sentences a Toronto man to four years in prison for trying to export nuclear-related items to Iran.

Kashmir Magazine

mag cover

 The magazine is available online at www.conveyormagazine.com
 

For The Record - Star

iqbal jassatharrath

January 27,2010 Edition 2

The Star reported yesterday in an article headlined "DStv channel chief executive granted interdict in Tunisian extradition case" that newspaper reports in the UK claimed that Media Review Network chairman Iqbal Jassat worked for Scotland Yard as an adviser on preventing terrorism. This is incorrect. In fact, reports in British newspapers suggested that Mohamed Ali Harrath, the chief executive of the London-based Islam Channel, worked for Scotland Yard.
 

Cartoon

plaster
 

Who's Online

We have 46 guests online

Popular

© 2010 Media Review | Go Fish Client Catchers - Internet Marketing - Search Engine Optimization (SEO)